LiFePo4 BMS & Balancers: Anyone use Heltec?


Author Message
KeepIS

Guru

Joined: 13/10/2014
Location: Australia
Posts: 1877
Posted: 10:17pm 24 Mar 2025      

  flyingfishfinger said  EDIT: I think I figured out part of it. The BMS boxes include PASSIVE balancing, whereas the capactive devices are ACTIVE. Therefore the theresholds for balancing in the passive should be overridden by the actively managed one, and I should be able to use both devices together correctly.


This is typically of most BMS devices that include passive balancing. Most BMS devices allow you to set Balance start voltage, Delta, and to either enable or disable passive balance.

I've tried combinations in testing and never seen any problems, with an external higher current active balancer and the BMS internal passive balancer, I've never seen any CELL conflict on my four parallel 53V banks, but IMHO passive balance is fine for NEW matched CELLS, but it also depends on charge current and other battery build variables, over time as batteries age I've found Active balancing to be very effective.

I do an occasional top balance once a year as I don't fully charge the LiFePO4 banks.

I see some newer BMS mention inbuilt active balance, but you need to check if the max balance current in these is comparable to an external Active balancer.
.
Edited 2025-03-28 07:42 by KeepIS